A Romanian company wins a project in Germany and wants to send its team there for a few months. The first question is almost always the same: do we need an A1? The answer is yes. The problem is that many stop there, while A1 solves only one part of the file.
What the A1 certificate actually determines
A1 is a portable document showing which social security legislation a person is subject to during a cross-border activity. That is all. Nothing more.
The basis is article 12(1) of Regulation (EC) No 883/2004:
The practical effect is simple and valuable: during the posting, contributions stay in Romania and are not paid twice.
What A1 is not
This is where the most expensive misunderstandings arise. A1 is not:
- a visa or residence permit;
- a right to work in the host country;
- an exemption from the host country minimum wage and working conditions;
- proof that the operation is a provision of services rather than a supply of labour.
Each of these four is checked separately, under its own rules.
The conditions examined on issue
Genuine activity in Romania. A registered address is not enough. The posting company must carry out substantial activity in Romania, not merely exist on paper.
The employment relationship is maintained. The link with the Romanian employer must exist before departure and continue throughout the posting.
Prior affiliation. The person must be subject to Romanian social security legislation before the posting. Administrative practice looks for a period of prior affiliation, and shorter situations are assessed case by case.
Temporary character. An anticipated duration of no more than 24 months, and not replacing another posted person. Beyond that threshold an exceptional agreement between the competent institutions of the states involved is required.
Genuine provision of services. If the people work under the direction and control of the foreign company, the operation looks more like a supply of labour than a provision of services, and the legal regime changes.
Third-country nationals: what is possible and where it stops
A Nepali, Indian or Uzbek worker legally employed in Romania can fall within the coordination rules through Regulation (EU) No 1231/2010, which extends those rules to third-country nationals legally resident in a Member State.
But there is a limit here that many do not know and that ruins whole plans: this extension does not cover every destination. Denmark does not apply Regulation No 1231/2010, and the instrument does not extend to the EFTA states, namely Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland, nor to the United Kingdom.
Concretely: for a non-EU worker, an A1 issued in Romania works towards Germany, Italy or the Netherlands, but it does not solve the situation towards Denmark, Norway or Switzerland. If the project is there, it is a different conversation from the start.
A1 and Vander Elst are not the same thing
A right of residence and work in Romania does not automatically create a right to work in another Member State.
A Nepali worker with a Romanian permit can travel to Germany. Whether he may actually work there is assessed separately: a visa, a work right, or an applicable exemption. In certain temporary service situations the Vander Elst procedure comes into play, built on the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Keep the distinction in mind: A1 answers "where are contributions paid", Vander Elst answers "is he allowed to work there". Having the first does not settle the second.
Two different clocks: 24 months and 12 months
Posting has two parallel regimes, with durations that do not coincide. Confusing them is common.
| Regime | What it governs | Duration |
|---|---|---|
| Regulation No 883/2004 | Social security, the A1 certificate | 24 months |
| Directive 96/71/EC, as amended by Directive 2018/957 | Working conditions and pay in the host country | 12 months, extendable to 18 on motivated notification |
During the posting, the host country minimum wage, working time, rest periods, health and safety rules and sectoral provisions apply. The fact that the employment relationship stays in Romania does not change that.
Where A1 is obtained in Romania
A1 certificates are issued by Casa Naţională de Pensii Publice. Applications are filed through the RODPA1 electronic portal at a1.cnpp.ro.
The assessment covers the company's activity, the employment situation of the workers, the destination state, the nature of the service and the duration of the posting.
Five mistakes that cost money
- Assuming that because people are on the Romanian payroll, a right to work in another Member State follows automatically.
- Treating A1 as a work permit or a visa.
- Planning a posting without genuine economic activity in Romania.
- Ignoring pay, working conditions and notification obligations in the host country.
- Confusing provision of services with supply of labour. In Germany, supplying staff to work under another undertaking's direction falls under temporary agency work legislation and requires a separate permit.
Before you promise anything to the client
Posting is not an administrative formality settled with a form. It is a construction in which three things must hold at the same time: the company's situation in Romania, the status of each worker, and the rules of the destination country.
We handle the Romanian side: recruitment, authorisation, contracts and the administration of foreign workers. If you are preparing a project in another Member State and want to know whether the Romanian side holds up before you commit to a client, write to us.

Romana
English
Türkçe